Assessing social impact through theory of change in voluntourism

Plinio Limata

Abstract


In recent years, voluntourism has been growing, catching the attention of academic research. Academic interest focused on investigating the specificity of this phenomenon, its definition and its impact, but more need to be done on assessing impact from host communities and stakeholders’ point of view, being able to identify reliable indicators that could be generally relevant and applicable.

The paper aims at identifying a set of the most relevant indicators for assessing the social and economic impact on host communities and stakeholders in the voluntourism sector in the light of the Theory of Change.

In order to achieve the expected results, a literature review has been carried out on three main topics: Voluntourism, Theory of change and Social Impact Assessment. To the extent of recognizing the proper indicators, a specific case study of a hybrid enterprise working in Italy will be selected for its peculiarities, in order to carry out in-depth interviews to its stakeholders and therefore reach the aforementioned goal of this paper.  


Keywords


voluntourism; theory of change; social impact assessment

Full Text:

PDF

References


Anderson A.A., (n.a.). “The Community Builder’s Approach to Theory of Change – A practical guide to theory development”, The Aspen Institute Roundtable on community change.

Anderson A.A. (2004). “Theory of Change as a tool for strategic planning – a report on early experiences”, The Aspen Institute Roundtable on community change.

Annie E. Casey Foundation (2004). “Theory of Change: A Practical Tool For Action, Results and Learning”, Annie E. Casey Foundation.

Arvidson M., Lyon F., McKay S., Moro D. (2010). “The ambitions and challenges of SROI”, Third Sector Research Centre, Working Paper 49.

Axelrod, M. D., 1976, “The dynamics of the group interview”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol. 3, Issue 1.

Benson A.M. (edited By) (2011). “Volunteer Tourism: Theory framework to practical applications”, Contemporary Geographies of leisure, tourism and Mobility, London: Routledge.

Blackman D.A., Benson A.M (2010). “The Role of the Psychological Contract in Managing Research Volunteer Tourism”, Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing, 27:3, 221-235.

Brown, S. (2005) Travelling with a purpose: understanding the motives and benefits of volunteer vacationers. Current Issues in Tourism 8, 479–496.

Butcher J., Smith P. (2010). “Making a difference: volunteer tourism and development”, Tourism Recreation Research, Vol. 35(1), 27–36.

Clark C., Rosenzweig W., Long D., Olsen S. (2004). “Double Bottom Line Project Report: Assessing Social impact in double bottom line ventures”. Retrieved from http://www.riseproject.org/DBL_Methods_Catalog.pdf

Conran M. (2011). “They really love me – Intimacy”, Volunteer Tourism in Annals of Tourism Research”, Vol. 38, No. 4, pp. 1454–1473.

Connell J., Kubish A. (1998). “Applying a theory of change approach to the evaluation of comprehensive community initiatives”, the Aspen Institute.

Corlazzoli V., White J. (2013). “Practical Approaches to Theories of Change in Conflict, Security, and Justice Programmes – Part II: Using Theories of Change in Monitoring and Evaluation”, UK Department for International Development (DFID).

Davies R. (2012), “Criteria for assessing the evaluability of a Theory of Change”, http://mandenews.blogspot.co.uk/2012/04/criteria-for-assessing-evaluablity-of.html

Eisenhardt K.M. (1989). “Building theory from case study research”, Academy of Management review, Vol. 16, No 4, 532 -550.

Ellis J., Parkinson D., Wadia A. (2011), “Making connections – using a theory of change to develop planning and evaluation”, Charities Evaluation Services.

Epstein M.J., Yuthas K. (2014). “Measuring and improving social impacts”, Barret-Koelher Publishers.

Eyben R., Kidder T., Rowlands J., Bronstein A. (2008). “Thinking about change for development practice: a case study from Oxfam GB”, Development in Practice, 18:2, 201-212

Eyben R. (2013). “Uncovering the politics of evidence and results. A framing paper for development practitioners”, background paper for a Big Push Forward Conference.

Fee L., Mdee A. (2011). “How does it make a difference? Towards accreditation of the development impact of volunteer tourism”, in Volunteer Tourism: Theory framework to practical applications (edited by Benson A.M.), Contemporary Geographies of leisure, tourism and Mobility, London: Routledge.

Grantcraft (n.a.). “Mapping change – Using a theory of change to guide planning and evaluation”.

Grieco C. (2015). Assessing social impact of social enterprises – does one size really fit all?, Springer.

Grieco C., Michelini L., Iasevoli G. (2014). “Measuring Value Creation in Social Enterprises: A cluster Analysis of Social Impact Assessment Models”, Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly, 1-21.

Harrison H., Birks M., Franklin R., Mills J. (2017). “Case Study Research: Foundations and Methodological Orientations”, Qualitative Social Research, Vol. 18, No 1.

Hehenberger L., Harling A.M., Scholten P. (2013). “A practical guide to measuring and managing impact”, European Venture Philanthropy Association.

Hivos (2015). “Theory of change in practice”, Hivos.

James C. (2011). “Theory Of Change Review - A report commissioned by Comic Relief”, Comic Relief.

Keystone (2008). “Developing a Theory of Change. A Framework for Accountability and Learning for Social Change And Learning with Constituents”.

Keystone (2009). “Developing a theory of change. A guide to developing a theory of change as a framework for inclusive dialogue, learning and accountability for social impact”, IPAL Guide 2.

Kubish A. (1997). “Voices from the Field: Learning from the Early Work of Comprehensive Community Initiatives”, The Aspen Institute.

Lawlor, E. (2009) Social return on investments: an approach to avoiding false economies, UKES Annual Conference.

Lyons, K.D., Wearing S. (edited by) (2008). “Journeys of Discovery in Volunteer Tourism – International Case Study Perspective”, Wallingford,UK: CABI Publishing.

Loiseau B., Darren B., Sibbald R., Raman S.A., Loh L.C. (2016). «How can a theory of change framework be applied to short term international volunteering?”, International Health, 8: 301-312.

Loiseau B., Sibbad R., Raman S.A., Darren B., Loh L.C., Dimaras H. (2016). “Perception of the role of short term volunteerism in international development: Views from Volunteers, Local hosts and Community Members”, Journal of Tropical Medicine, volume 2016.

Lupoli C.A., Morse W.C., Bailey C., Schelhas J. (2014). “Assessing the impacts of international volunteer tourism in host communities: a new approach to organizing and prioritizing indicators”, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 22:6, 898-921.

Lyons,K.D., Wearing S. (edited by) (2008). “Journeys of Discovery in Volunteer Tourism – International Case Study Perspective”,Wallingford,UK: CABI Publishing.

Lockie S. (2001). “SIA in review: setting the agenda for impact assessment in the 21st century”, Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 19:4, 277-287.

Mackenzie M., Blamey A. (2005). “The Practice and the Theory. Lessons from the Application of a Theories of Change Approach”, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

McGehee N.G., Santos C.A. (2005). “Social change, discourse and volunteer tourism”, Annals of Tourism Research, Vol. 32, No. 3, pp. 760–779.

Mdee, A. and Emmott, R. (2008) “Social enterprise with international impact: the case for fair trade certification of volunteer tourism”, Education, Knowledge and Economy 2(3).

Miles H., Huberman M. (1994). Qualitative data analysis: a sourcebook. Beverly Hill, CA: Sage.

Mustonen P. (2005). “Volunteer tourism – postmodern pilgrimage?”, National, European, Global. Research Seminar of Economic Sociology – Series Discussion and Working Paper 2.

Nigri G., Michelini L. (forthcoming). “A systematic literature review on Social Impact Assessment: outlining main dimensions and future research lines”.

Ober H. (2012). (2012). “Defining Theories of Change”, CARE International UK.

Palacios, C. (2010). Volunteer tourism, development and education in a postcolonial world: conceiving global connections beyond aid. Journal of Sustainable Tourism, 18(7), 861-878.

Perrini F., Russo A., Tencati A. (2007). CSR strategies of SMEs and large firms. Evidence from Italy. Journal of business ethics, 74 (3), 285-300.

Porter M.E., Hills G., Pfitzer M., Patscheke S., Hawkins E. (2012). “Measuring Shared Value. How to Unlock Value by Linking Social and Business Results”, FSG. Retrieved from http://www.fsg.org/Portals/0/Uploads/Documents/PDF/Measuring_Shared_Value.pdf

Porter M.E., Kramer M.R. (2011). “Creating Share Value”, Harvard Business Review, 62-77.

Raymond E.M., Hall M.H. (2008). “The development of cross cultural (mis)understanding through volunteer tourism”, Journal of Sustainable Tourism, Vol. 16, No 5.

Reeler D., (2016). “A three-fold Theory of Social Change. With implications for planning, monitoring and evaluation”, The Community Development Resource Association.

Reeler D. (2017). “Theories of Change. Concentrating on the truth of the work”, The Community Development Resource Association.

Richmond B.J., Mook L., Quarter J. (2003). “Social Accounting for Nonprofits. Two Models”, Nonprofit Management & Leadership, Vol. 13, No 4.

Shapiro I. (2005). “Theory of Change. Beyond Intractability”, Eds. Guy Burgess and Heidi Burgess, Conflict Information Consortium, University of Colorado, Boulder.

Shepherd, R. (2002) Commodification, culture and tourism. Tourist Studies, 2(2): 183–201.

Sherraden M.S., Lough B., McBride A.M. (2008). “Effects of International Volunteering and Service: Individual and Institutional Predictors”, Voluntas, No 19, 395-342.

Skoczylas, L. (2012). “Volunteer Tourism from the Perspective of the Social Sciences”, Tourism 22/2.

Social Impact Analysts Association. (2013). “How can organizations think about the practice of social impact analysis?” (Thought Paper). Retrieved from http://www.siaassociation.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/How-can-organisations-approach-the-practice-of-spcialimpact-analysis.pdf

Simpson, K. (2004). “‘Doing development’: the gap year, volunteer-tourists and a popular practice of development”. Journal of International Development, 16(5), 681-692.

Sin H.L. (2014), “Who are responsible to? Locals tales of volunteer tourism”, Geoforum, vol. 41, No.6, 983-992.

Stake, Robert E. (2006). Multiple case study analysis. New York, NY: Guilford.

Stein D., Valters C. (2012). “Understanding Theory of Change in International Development”, JSRP Paper 1.

Stern E., Stame N., Mayne J., Forss K., Davies R., Befani B. (2012). “Broadening the range of designs and methods for impact evaluations”, UK Department for International Development (DFID).

Taplin D.H., Clark H. (2012). “Theory of change basics – a primer on theory of change”, Actknowledge.

Taplin D.H., Clark H., Collins E., Colby D.C. (2013). “Theory of Change – Technical Papers – A series of papers to support development of Theories of Change on practice in the field”, Actknowledge.

Tellis, Winston, (1997). “Introduction to Case Study”, The Qualitative Report, Vol. 3, No 2, July (http://www.nova.edu/ssss/QR/QR3-2/tellis1.html).

Tomazos K. (2016), “Volunteer Tourism and living with contradiction: Symbiosis or just compromise?”, in ATLAS Annual Conference, 115 -118.

Valters C. (2014). “Theories of Change in International Development: Communication, Learning, or Accountability?”, JSRP Paper 17.

Van Der Knaap P. (2004). “Theory-based Evaluation and Learning: Possibilities and Challenges”, Evaluation, Vol. 10 (I), 16-34.

Vanclay F., (2003). “International Principles For Social Impact Assessment”, Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 21:1, 5-12.

Vanclay F. (2004). “The triple bottom line and impact assessment. How do TBL, EIA, SIA, SEA and EMS relate to each other?”, Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management, Vol. 6, No 3, 265 – 288.

Vanclay, F., Esteves, A.M., Aucamp, I. & Franks, D. (2015). “Social Impact Assessment: Guidance for assessing and managing the social impacts of projects”. International Association for Impact Assessment, http://www.iaia.org/uploads/pdf/SIA_Guidance_Document_IAIA.pdf

Vernuccio, M., Ceccotti, F., Pastore, A., (2012). “L’innovazione nella comunicazione integrata di marketing secondo gli attori del network. Una lettura con le mappe cognitive”. Sinergie 88, 93-113.

Vogel I. (2012), “Review of the use of ‘Theory of Change’ in international development – Review Report”, UK Department for International Development (DFID).

Voss C., Tsikriktsis N., Frohlich M. (2002). “Case research in operations management”, International Journal of Operations and Production Management, Vol. 22, Issue:2, 195-219.

Wearing S. (2003). “Volunteer Tourism”, Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing.

Wearing S. (2011). “Volunteer Tourism – Experiences that Makes a difference”, Wallingford, UK: CABI Publishing.

Wearing S., McGee N.G. (2013). “Volunteer Tourism: A Review”, Tourism Management, No 38, 120-130.

Weiss C. (1995). “Nothing as practical as Good Theory: Exploring Theory-Based for Comprehensive Community Initiatives for children and families”, in Cornell J. (1995) “New Approached to Evaluating Community Initiative”, The Aspen Institute.

Weiss C. (2007). “Theory-based evaluation: past, present and future”, New Directions For Evaluation, No. 76.

Yin R.K. (2014). “Case Study research: Design and Methods” (5th ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Zaidah Z. (2007). “Case study as a research method”, Journal Kemanusiaan, Vol. 9.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.